ENUGU, Nigeria (VOICE OF NAIJA)- A former President of the Court of Appeal, Isa Salami, has said that Peter Obi ought not to have been allowed to contest the 2023 presidential election under the Labour Party, citing constitutional and procedural issues.
Salami made the assertion on Tuesday in Ilorin, Kwara State, during a courtesy visit and award presentation by the Wole Soyinka Centre for Investigative Journalism.
The retired jurist blamed what he described as “inadequacy” among some judges for controversial rulings, noting that gaps in competence not necessarily dishonesty have led to questionable judicial outcomes.
“There are a few bad eggs amongst some judges. Strictly speaking, I will not say bad eggs. Some of them have a problem with learning. They don’t have a good background to be judges,” he said.
He criticised the appointment process within the judiciary, arguing that individuals without sufficient experience sometimes find their way to the bench.
READ ALSO: PDP Chieftain Confesses To Rigging 2023 Elections Against Peter Obi
“Imagine appointing a higher registrar as a judge. He has no experience. In the past, this would not have happened,” he added.
Citing Obi’s case, Salami argued that the former Anambra State governor did not meet the constitutional requirement to contest under the Labour Party.
“For instance, Peter Obi ought not be allowed to contest the 2023 presidential election. In the sense that by the time he lost the PDP primary, LP had submitted its list of members to the Independent National Electoral Commission. And the Constitution says there cannot be an independent candidacy.
“How did he become a candidate of LP if he does not belong to LP?” he queried.
He drew a parallel with the case of Kano State Governor Abba Yusuf, insisting that party membership registers, not issued cards, determine legitimacy.
“The same thing happened to the Governor of Kano State… His name is not in the NNPP’s register, but they issued him a membership card, and the register is supposed to be the mother of the card,” he said.
Salami further faulted the Supreme Court for upholding such outcomes, blaming it on structural issues in judicial appointments.
READ ALSO: 2027: I Reject Power-Driven Coalitions- Peter Obi
“But the Supreme Court countenanced it, even though the tribunal and Appeal Court frowned at it. That is the problem of competence,” he said.
According to him, promotions to the apex court are sometimes influenced by zonal considerations rather than merit, leading to experienced judges being bypassed.
“People get to the Supreme Court not because they are good but because there is a vacancy in their zone,” he added.
Despite his criticisms, Salami expressed appreciation to the WSCIJ for the honour, describing it as a recognition many judges would value.
“I am very happy to receive the award. There is hardly any judge who will not appreciate this type of award,” he said.
He also credited Wole Soyinka for shaping his principles, while recalling how Obafemi Awolowo influenced his decision to study law.
“In fact, Chief Awolowo was the one who influenced my decision to read law during his treasonable felony trial,” he said.


